There are a lot of great feedback models out there.
But they all miss a key point.
Many of my clients are trying to create a culture of feedback within their companies. They want to be innovative and iterative and that relies on employees being willing to give open and honest feedback to one another.
The good news is that there are a lot of techniques out there to help people give feedback. I have even taught several of them.
SBI stands for Situation, Behavior, Impact.
“Yesterday, when you were leading the project update meeting, you did a really great job of making sure every question got answered. It really helped make sure we were all on the same page.”
COIN stands for Context, Observation, Impact, Next Steps.
“During our team meeting last week, I noticed that you were about 10 minutes late to the meeting. This meant you missed several important updates from some of the team members, including ones that impact your projects. I really need you to make sure you are on time from now on.”
These techniques and others are great, but they miss one key difference between effective feedback and ineffective feedback.
When I talk with managers who are struggling to give feedback to certain members of their team, they often have a similar mindset. They don’t really believe the person can respond to the feedback. This can come in many different forms.
They don’t think they are a good fit for the team.
They don’t think the person actually cares about their role.
Whatever the reason, it is the mindset that is going to poison their attempts to give feedback. Until you truly believe the person can change, and you genuinely want to help them change, any feedback you give is going to be ineffective.
Being a good manager is all about believing in your people. You have to believe in them when they don’t believe in themselves. You have to believe in them, even when they make mistakes.
It is that belief that will allow you to approach them with a full heart and say, this is what you are doing wrong and I want to help you.
“What if they don’t deserve that belief,” you might be asking.
Give it to them anyway.
It is only by trusting them with that belief that you can give feedback in a way that has the best shot at being successful. After a few tries that are still not successful, you have given it your best shot. Now the time for feedback is over.
Though feedback techniques are great, the best message will still sound bad if it comes from a bad place. The next time you give feedback, spend a few moments to put yourself in the right frame of mind to give feedback that you truly want to be helpful.
That is your best chance at success.

