Do managers even matter?

My background gives me a strange take on this. I started in the military where leadership is all that matters. Every few years I would be sent to a multi-week training on how to be a better leader. We were constantly talking about it. Leadership ability was almost more important than technical ability.

Then I went to SpaceX.

Actually, I don’t want to call out SpaceX. Then I went into the tech/start-up world and found that many people didn’t know what managers or leaders were for. Technical ability was almost all that was valued. If you became a manager, you were lucky if you got more than an hour or two of training on what it means to be a leader, otherwise it was up to you to figure out.

I find this strange because one of the most successful tech companies on the planet, Google, answered the question about managers mattering over a decade ago.

In 2011, Google released the results of Project Oxygen. This was a 4 year study where they were trying to figure out if managers made a difference.

Here is what they found.

  • Teams with better managers were more productive, had higher quality outputs, and met their targets more consistently compared to teams with low-scoring managers.
  • Employees working under highly effective managers reported higher levels of job satisfaction, in some cases as much as 30%.
  • Teams with effective managers saw attrition rate drop by 20-30% compared to those with lower-performing managers.
  • Employee Engagement scores could be 15-20% higher for teams with great managers.

They didn’t just define the impact of great managers. They were also able to define eight behaviors that led to these kinds of results.

  1. Be a good coach.
  2. Empower the team and do not micromanage.
  3. Express interest in team members’ success and well-being.
  4. Be productive and results-oriented.
  5. Be a good communicator—listen and share information.
  6. Help the team with career development.
  7. Have a clear vision/strategy for the team.
  8. Possess key technical skills to help advise the team.

Given the analytical rigor applied to Project Oxygen, I think it is one of the most important leadership studies ever done. 

Yet we have kind of forgotten about it.

For that reason, I am going to spend a bit of time on it with this newsletter. For the next four weeks, I will be picking two of these behaviors and diving a bit deeper. You can expect to not just learn why the behavior is important but get some simple tips you can immediately apply to improve your own performance.

I hope you come along for the ride.

You may be interested in