Do managers even matter?
My background gives me a strange take on this. I started in the military where leadership is all that matters. Every few years I would be sent to a multi-week training on how to be a better leader. We were constantly talking about it. Leadership ability was almost more important than technical ability.
Then I went to SpaceX.
Actually, I don’t want to call out SpaceX. Then I went into the tech/start-up world and found that many people didn’t know what managers or leaders were for. Technical ability was almost all that was valued. If you became a manager, you were lucky if you got more than an hour or two of training on what it means to be a leader, otherwise it was up to you to figure out.
I find this strange because one of the most successful tech companies on the planet, Google, answered the question about managers mattering over a decade ago.
In 2011, Google released the results of Project Oxygen. This was a 4 year study where they were trying to figure out if managers made a difference.
Here is what they found.
- Teams with better managers were more productive, had higher quality outputs, and met their targets more consistently compared to teams with low-scoring managers.
- Employees working under highly effective managers reported higher levels of job satisfaction, in some cases as much as 30%.
- Teams with effective managers saw attrition rate drop by 20-30% compared to those with lower-performing managers.
- Employee Engagement scores could be 15-20% higher for teams with great managers.
They didn’t just define the impact of great managers. They were also able to define eight behaviors that led to these kinds of results.
- Be a good coach.
- Empower the team and do not micromanage.
- Express interest in team members’ success and well-being.
- Be productive and results-oriented.
- Be a good communicator—listen and share information.
- Help the team with career development.
- Have a clear vision/strategy for the team.
- Possess key technical skills to help advise the team.
Given the analytical rigor applied to Project Oxygen, I think it is one of the most important leadership studies ever done.
Yet we have kind of forgotten about it.
For that reason, I am going to spend a bit of time on it with this newsletter. For the next four weeks, I will be picking two of these behaviors and diving a bit deeper. You can expect to not just learn why the behavior is important but get some simple tips you can immediately apply to improve your own performance.
I hope you come along for the ride.

