Is diversity hiring costing lives?
It might be if you listen to Elon Musk.
During a recent interview with Don Lemon, Elon said that any time you aren’t focusing on the core performance metrics of the role, you are by definition lowering the hiring standards. Meaning that focusing on diversity for pilots, surgeons, etc, will at the margin cost lives.
Rather than diving into the details of equality or equity and the history of racism in America, I want to go a different direction in this discussion.
I want to quote the movie Miracle.
For those of you who don’t know, Miracle is the 2004 movie that told the story of the 1980 U.S. Olympic Hockey team and their dramatic defeat of the Soviet Union. (Yes, I am talking about diversity by referencing a movie about a historical event involving all white people.)
Early in the movie, while looking at the list of players who would be on the team, the assistance coach, Craig Patrick, says to the head coach, Herb Brooks, “You are missing some of the best players.”
Herb responds simply, “I’m not looking for the best players Craig, I am looking for the right ones.”
To me, there isn’t a better case for diversity in hiring than that quote.
The goal of a manager is to build the best team. The best team isn’t necessarily the highest performing individuals. The best team is the team that can create the best ideas, work together the most effectively, and ultimately produce the best results. AS A TEAM.
If everyone on your team graduated from the same school, grew up doing the same things, and has largely lived the same life, you aren’t going to have the same diversity of ideas you could potentially have.
This changes how we view the question of “who is most qualified?”
Pretend for a moment that there are only two qualities of a candidate you can look at, G.P.A. and gender. You have two candidates, a male and a female. The male’s G.P.A. is 3.8 and the female’s G.P.A. is 3.9. Let’s also say you have a four-person team who are currently all females.
I would argue that the male candidate is the most qualified candidate. The unique perspective he is likely to bring will make the team better. Even though his “technical” quality is lower.
To prove this idea in the real world, McKinsey found that companies with an above average level of diversity were more likely to achieve above average profits.
As a manager, it is your job to build the strongest team. That doesn’t just come down to looking at the performance of people you hire. You also want to think about the other qualities and ideas they are bringing to the team.
That kind of diversity makes a positive impact.

