Episode Description
In this episode of Leadership Launchpad, we explore one of the most common pitfalls for new managers: the pacesetting leadership style. Drawing from Daniel Goleman's six leadership styles, the discussion highlights the strengths and severe downsides of consistently using a pacesetting approach. The episode delves into why many technical managers and strong individual contributors fall into this trap, emphasizing how it can lead to micromanagement, team burnout, and reduced decision-making authority among team members. Practical tips are provided on how to diversify one's leadership style, including techniques for coaching team members and redistributing tasks more effectively to ensure long-term team success. Whether you're a new manager or an experienced leader, this episode offers valuable insights into developing a more balanced and effective leadership approach.
---
Want more tips on effective training? Sign-up for our weekly newsletter: https://www.bettereverydaystudios.com/newsletter
Visit us at https://www.bettereverydaystudios.com
Matt Gjertsen [00:00:00]:
If this is, this is a really great style when it's used in conjunction with some of the others. But if it's just pace setting all the time, what you're going to find is that just other people feel like they don't have decision making authority. They're not able to figure things out for themselves. You can come off as overbearing, you can come off as micromanaging. And so it can be really negative. Whenever I'm working with new people leaders, one of the first things I talk about is leadership styles, because many people aren't exposed to that many different leaders early in their career. And so they might think that the style of their last manager kind of is leadership. And so by explaining to them that there are all these different styles, different ways to lead, and that the best way to be a leader is to get good at all of these different styles, it really sets them up for success.
Matt Gjertsen [00:01:00]:
But the interesting thing is, is when I'm working with these new leaders, especially technical managers or really strong individual contributors, they tend to fall into one specific leadership style, which is kind of a trap. And that's why I want to talk about it today. So welcome to the leadership launchpad. My name is Matt Jurtson. I'm excited for this first solo episode of 2025. That doesn't even sound like a real year to me. It's just crazy. If you've ever listened to me talk about leadership styles before, you probably know that I always talk about Daniel Goleman's work and the six leadership styles that he identified in an HBR article 25 years ago.
Matt Gjertsen [00:01:43]:
And so I want to start by going over those leadership styles and then highlight the one that is kind of a common pitfall I see for new technical managers and then talk about some ways that you can get out of it. So the six leadership styles that Goldman talks about, and I highly recommend you read this article because it's titled Leadership that Gets Results. And the first leadership style is a commanding leadership style where it's very much like, do what I say, you know, giving orders, barking orders, that kind of thing. Very, very authoritative. There's the visionary leadership style, which is, you know, rallying people around some view of the future that you're going to go create. And it's going to be amazing. Let's go. Follow me.
Matt Gjertsen [00:02:23]:
We're going to go do this amazing thing you have pace setting, which is about do things, how you know, I'm going to show you how to do these things. Follow me. I'm going to tell you the best way to do everything. Let's go. Affiliative leadership really prioritizes relationship building on a team. So you may even sacrifice short term performance on the team or, you know, not give certain kinds of feedback because you really value building relationships between a team. There's the democratic leadership style where when you're making decisions, it's all about, you know, making sure everybody's heard, getting to a consensus, just judging the opinions of the whole team. And then finally there's the coaching leadership style where you spend the majority of your time really focusing on the, you know, long term bench depth of the talent on your team, helping each individual, that kind of thing.
Matt Gjertsen [00:03:14]:
The important thing, the first important thing to understand about all these leadership styles is that there is not one best leadership style. There is only the leadership style that is best in a specific situation. And in the article, Goleman goes into research where they were kind of trying to connect each individual leadership style with performance of teams out in the workplace. And they did find some of that. But the key finding to me is that the best leaders always were able to exhibit at least four of the leadership styles. So depending on the situation, depending on the individual that they were working with, they would change their leadership style. And so coming back to new managers, most of us probably have our preferences for the kind of leader that we naturally are. And it's likely based on, it's based on our personality and then also based on the kinds of leadership that we've seen in the past.
Matt Gjertsen [00:04:10]:
And so we kind of pick up those traits and then start applying them to as, as a leader. And so new leaders tend to have one or two styles that they're kind of really good at and rely on. And then the point of developing them as leaders is to get them to focus on new things. And this is something that I do a lot in my programs where I ask people, you know, what's a style that you're weakest at? Let's identify a particular behavior of that style and let's figure out how we can, you know, strengthen some of those other styles so that you basically have more tools in your tool belt. And this is something that any leader at any, at any level and any amount of experience should probably be, be thinking about and be working on. But the interesting thing that I've found is that the most common leadership style I see in new people, managers, and especially really strong individual contributors that were just promoted is the pacesetter style. And so I want to spend a minute talking about it because I When I took kind of the assessment for these leadership styles, when I first learned about them, I, I will admit that I was a pacesetter and at first I was really excited because you read the description of a pacesetter. Kind of like I said before, leading from the front, showing the team the best way to work pushes really strong results, has really high standards, attention to detail, let's go.
Matt Gjertsen [00:05:31]:
Like, yeah, that sounds, that's, that's, that sounds like a great leader. But then you realize, then you keep reading and you see the effect that it has on the team. And it's, it's one of only two leadership styles that over the long term has a negative effect on teams. It creates, you know, it makes people apathetic, it makes, it demoralizes them. It leads to burnout. And so if you think, if you think about it a little bit closer, it makes sense because, you know, yay, you're out there, you know, showing people what to do. But that can really easily tip over into micromanagement. Right? And also I think, you know, if somebody has been promoted, especially when they first get promoted to being a people leader, they're promoted because of their individual excellence, right? They were the best individual contributor and so they were made a people manager.
Matt Gjertsen [00:06:29]:
And so almost by definition, your performance standard is too high for other people on the team to meet automatically without you helping them. And so you try to hold this high standard for everybody and what it leads you to do is just, you know, give them the answer instead of letting them come to the answer. It means you do things yourself rather than letting the team do it because you're worried they're not going to do it as good as you are. You don't, you know, you don't give a lot of coaching. And granted, if this is, this is a really great style when it's used in conjunction with some of the others. But if it's just pace setting all the time, we're always saying, like, let's go, like, follow. We're in the trenches together. Many times what you're going to find is that just other people feel like they don't have decision making authority.
Matt Gjertsen [00:07:17]:
They're not able to figure things out for themselves. You can come off as overbearing, you can come off as micromanaging. And so it can be really negative. And that's why I say it's a trap. If it's such a trap, why does everybody, why do so many people fall into this? Well, I think like I said, you know, there's a couple there's a couple reasons for this. One of which I already mentioned is the idea that, like, the reason why you were promoted was because you had this really high standard of work. And so you start looking at other people and you're thinking like, they can't do it as good as I do. This was a common thing in the military.
Matt Gjertsen [00:07:52]:
In the military, we always joked that every commander, when they got promoted, when they got a new job, they were always trying to do their last job, right? Like a group commander was trying to be a squadron commander, a wing commander was trying to be a group commander. It's because they knew how to do that job. And so when they got promoted, they didn't know this new thing. And so their default was to just fall back and say, I'm going to keep doing that last thing. And that's what can happen. You get promoted, you don't know how to be people manager yet. And so you just say, well, I, I'm already the best at all this individual contributor work. So I'm just, I'm just going to do that.
Matt Gjertsen [00:08:23]:
So that's why it's really easy to fall into. The other reason is because sometimes I don't think we do a good enough job explaining what the role of a people manager is. And as an individual contributor, you were judged on your individual output of work, but now as a people manager, you are judged by the collective output of your team. And so it's just a little switch where you need to stop thinking about what can I do and start thinking about what can we do. And if we don't do a good enough job explaining that, then people don't make that switch. So of all these six leadership styles, pace setting is the most common one. It is understandable why individual contributors fall into that. And yet it is a trap that can lead to negative impact on the team.
Matt Gjertsen [00:09:13]:
So how do we get out of this? The nice thing is, is that it's, it can be pretty easy once you, if you, if you are sitting here listening to this and thinking, I might be a pacesetter or I'm maybe I'm relying on pace setting. Too much awareness, I think is the key. And so like some simple ways that you can do this and make sure you're trying to, trying to step back. Number one is when somebody comes to you with a problem, don't immediately give them a solution. Ask them what they think the solution is. Employ a little bit of coaching in this situation, right? Or maybe have them work with somebody else on the team, say so and so is really covering this really well or really knows that system or that program or whatever it is really well, maybe you can go ask them. It might feel like you're not being helpful, but what you are doing is empowering your team to solve problems themselves, right? It is not your job to solve every problem for your, the members of your team. It is your job to empower them to solve their own problems.
Matt Gjertsen [00:10:21]:
There's going to be enough things that they can't solve, right? Because of, you know, just like hierarchy within a company, that's where you come in, right? When you need resources from outside the team, that's where you can really come in. And sure, I'm not saying never give a solution, but from time to time, if you think you're maybe relying a little bit too much on pace setting, just from time to time, when people come to you with a question, ask them what they think the answer is. Don't just jump right in. So that's, that's number one. Number two, really, and this is really important, really, really hesitate or stop. When you think about, like taking over other people's work or when new work comes into your team, don't immediately think that you need to do it. Think about who else on your team can do it. Again, from an individual contributor mindset, it feels like you're passing off work like you're not doing your job.
Matt Gjertsen [00:11:12]:
But the point is you have a new job and every new thing that comes onto your plate is taking time away from you, coaching your team, growing your team, getting obstacles out of their way, getting more resources, doing whatever it is to make the overall team more successful. So you need to. So that's the second, you know, the second thing is flip that switch in your mind. And rather than every time a new task comes in thinking, how am I going to do it? Think about how we are going to do it. I've heard this described a lot of times for business leaders as you know, it's changing the mindset from how or what to who. Right? It's not how am I going to do this, it's who's going to do this and when you can make that transition. That's when you're really getting into the people manager thought process versus the individual contributor mindset. And so if you can do just those two things, just when somebody comes to you says like, hey, we got to do this thing or I have this problem, don't immediately give them a solution.
Matt Gjertsen [00:12:14]:
And then when new work comes in, don't immediately think, how am I going to do this, think who is best to do this. If you can make those two switches, I guarantee you're going to go a long way out of, you know, because you don't want to get rid of pace setting. Don't get me wrong. Like again, when we look at Goldman's work, he made very clear long term is when this is bad, there are definitely situations, there's emergency situations, something's going wrong, you know, the system's down, it's all hands on deck. You are this great individual contributor and there are key moments where you can come in and show your team, especially on technical teams, show your team that you're still technically savvy, that you know what's going on, that you're able to, you know that you have, that you have the skills to lead this team. You definitely still need to do that, but you can't always do that. There are many times you need to be thinking about who else you know. You need to be empowering the team to solve problems because that is how you are going to make your team more successful over the long term.
Matt Gjertsen [00:13:15]:
If you think you're a pacesetter, if you know you're a pacesetter, I hope you found this helpful and I will see you next time time on the leadership launchpad. Thank you so much for listening to today's show. If you are looking for help turning your organization's great engineers into great managers, me and my team at Better Everyday Studios would love to help. We deliver targeted and interactive training workshops that are designed to help build the three fundamental skills of any new manager. Building trust, giving feedback and setting goals. Reach out to me through Matt better everyday studios.com so we can start making your organization better every day.

