In this episode of Leadership Launchpad, the conversation explores why giving and receiving feedback is challenging, especially for technical managers. The discussion focuses on evolutionary and social reasons behind feedback anxiety and emphasizes the importance of a structured approach to feedback. Drawing from lessons in the book Minimum Viable Manager, listeners are introduced to actionable strategies, including the SBI (Situation, Behavior, Impact) and COIN feedback models. The episode outlines a three-step plan for building a high-feedback culture: starting by asking for feedback, giving reinforcing feedback, and finally delivering redirecting feedback. Practical examples and phased implementation advice offer a roadmap for leaders to improve team performance and foster trust.
Important Moments:
- 00:00: Introduction to feedback and common challenges
- 01:15: Overview of the First Principles Leadership framework
- 02:04: Evolutionary and social roots of feedback anxiety
- 05:48: The importance of feedback for improvement
- 07:14: Three-step plan for giving and receiving feedback
- 09:45: SBI feedback model example and reinforcing feedback
- 10:54: COIN model for redirecting feedback
- 12:34: Phased approach to building feedback culture
- 13:34: Preview of next episode and conclusion
Matt Gjertsen [00:00:00]:
Very often, even for, especially for our best performers, we're often like, oh, they're just awesome. They get it. I promise you, they don't get it. If you think your team feels valued, they probably don't unless you are specifically telling them. Hello and welcome to the Leadership Launchpad where we help technical managers improve themselves, their teams, and their organizations. If you are a technical manager, an engineer technician looking to become a technical manager, or you are someone who helps technical managers, this is the show to get actionable insights from people who have been in the trenches before on how to improve your own performance and the performance of those around you. If you don't know, Minimum Viable Manager, my first book, is now out everywhere books are sold. I can't tell you the feedback that I've been getting on this has been absolutely amazing, that, that I just love, you know, You know, I— this is 2 years of my life spent distilling down 20 years of experience working in the Air Force, SpaceX, Atoms, the whole startup world.
Matt Gjertsen [00:01:05]:
It's, it's been a really, really amazing experience. And this episode today is the 3rd in a 4-part series where we're diving into each part of this book. As a reminder, this book is, is based on this idea of a framework that I call First Principles Leadership, which says a leader, in order to be successful, has to do 3 things. They have to get people to work together, they have to get them working on the right things, and they have to improve their work over time. Minimum Viable Manager means the first step in all 3 of those: building trust, setting expectations, and giving feedback. If you're just new to this show, go back and listen to the last 2 episodes so that you know what is building up to this point, because today We are talking about feedback. We're gonna talk about why feedback is important, what makes feedback good, and then finally how you can start giving more feedback on your team. So let's get started.
Matt Gjertsen [00:02:04]:
Why is feedback so difficult? I think I've stood in front of so many rooms of people where I ask, you know, can whatever— raise your hand if feedback was helpful in getting you to where you are today. And everybody raises their hand. I say, okay, raise your hand if you struggle giving feedback, and everybody raises their hand, right? It's just one of those things that we all struggle with, and I want to tell you it's okay. It's not your fault. Biology designed you to struggle with giving feedback. And so I think there's 3 simple reasons. These— this is my takeaways. These aren't facts necessarily, but these are 3 reasons that I have.
Matt Gjertsen [00:02:40]:
Like, first off, The reason why feedback is difficult is because we have a natural negativity bias that's built into us by evolution. I always use the example of you're walking through a field, you know, 20,000 years ago, and you see some, you see some grass rustle. Maybe it's the wind, or maybe it's a lion. And at this point, there's 2 different worlds, right? You can assume there's a lion, or you, and you can run away, or you can keep walking. Right? And then there either is a lion or there isn't a lion. In a world where you assume the best outcome, it's, it's just the wind and you keep walking. Well, now you have a 50/50 shot because either the lion's there or it's not. So 50/50 shot of living.
Matt Gjertsen [00:03:22]:
If you assume the worst case that it is a lion and you run away, you live every time. I know that's a really simple example, but it illustrates this idea that over millions of years, thousands of these, millions of these situations, It's just obvious that the evolutionary advantage goes to believing bad things are going to happen, so then you take action to avoid those bad things. So we just have this inbuilt negativity bias. The second challenge that adds to that is that we as human beings are social creatures. We evolved to survive as a pack, right, where we were all in a tribe together, and if we were pushed out of that tribe, if we faced social isolation, we were more likely to die. And so what that means is they've done fMRI scans on our brains where they've looked, they've exposed people to both physical pain and social pain, and we feel social pain in a very similar way to physical pain. And it's because of this idea that we're social creatures where being isolated socially, being pushed out of the group, was physically dangerous to us. So when somebody says, hey, I have some feedback for you, the first thing that happens is we have this negativity bias that kicks in and says, oh my gosh, it's going to be bad feedback.
Matt Gjertsen [00:04:41]:
And then we go into this spiral because, oh my gosh, I'm getting pushed out of the group, I'm going to lose my job, I'm not going to be able to pay for my house or my food or my family. And it causes us to freak out. So that's why it's difficult to receive feedback, those 2 things. Why is it difficult to feed— give feedback? I think a lot of this comes down to something called mirror neurons, where in our brains there's these— there are these neurons where when we see someone else experiencing something, we experience it to a lesser degree as well. That's why you can— if you are a basketball player and you watch people playing basketball, it can actually make you better at playing basketball. But also, if you see somebody else in pain or distress, you feel pain and distress. So it is the basis of learning, also of empathy, right? And so when we're getting ready to give somebody feedback, we know how— what they're going to experience, that negativity bias and the fact that we're social creatures. And so then we pre-feel their feelings, and it makes us all nervous, and it becomes this weird spiral inside of our heads.
Matt Gjertsen [00:05:48]:
So I say all that to say, it's not just you. You were designed to struggle both receiving and giving feedback. Challenge is, what do you do now? Because you got to give it, right? You have to give feedback if you want your team to improve. You need to create an environment of feedback if you want your team to improve. So you have to come up with a way to give that feedback. And you have to come up with a way to give that feedback in a way that is actually going to be good, because there's been a lot of meta-analyses that show 1/3 of feedback actually makes performance worse. So if you don't have a clear and consistent way of delivering feedback, you are actually at risk of making your team worse, right? If you're not clear about what they're doing, if you're not clear about what you want them to improve, then it's just going to create a whole bunch of emotion and make Just a quick interjection. I wanted to remind you that I run a company called Built, where we train the next generation of hard tech leaders how to build teams capable of solving the world's hardest problems.
Matt Gjertsen [00:06:53]:
If you are an aspiring technical leader, an existing leader, or responsible for training leaders in your organization, please check out builtleaders.com to see if we can support you and your team. So what do we do now? What should you do now? I break this up into 3 basic parts. I think there's a 3-step plan for improving your ability to give feedback. Step 1 is ask for feedback. If your team doesn't have a high feedback culture yet and you want to start it, the first thing you need to do is show that you value feedback by asking for it. But you can't ask it by simply saying, hey, do you have any feedback for me? This is a problem for 2 reasons. For 2 reasons. One, the word you— do you have any feedback.
Matt Gjertsen [00:07:38]:
You're putting the onus all on them, which puts a lot of pressure on them and makes it most likely they're going to say like, oh no, you're great. Second thing is any feedback. It's this really— it's wide open, creates a blank page syndrome. So if you want to ask for feedback from your team, you need to start asking for feedback that assumes there is feedback and is very specific, right? So it's not, do you have any feedback for me? It's, hey, in the meeting yesterday What's one thing I could have done to improve how I led that meeting? It's that simple, right? It narrows the focus, gives their brain something to latch onto, and makes it open to them to say something where you're actually gonna, actually gonna, you know, do something about it because you're the one asking for it. It makes them feel more comfortable giving you that feedback. So that's step one, is you need to start asking for more. feedback. Step 2 is to start giving feedback, but giving only what I call reinforcing feedback.
Matt Gjertsen [00:08:38]:
I take feedback and I break it up into 2 different types of feedback, reinforcing and redirecting. So what do I want you to keep doing and what do I want you to change? We always wanna start with the reinforcement. What do I want you to keep doing? And this is usually either skipped over or done incorrectly, right? Very often, even for, especially for our best performers, we're often like, oh, they're just awesome. They get it. I promise you they don't get it. If you think your team feels valued, they probably don't unless you are specifically telling them. So first, the one— the first reason to give feedback on— give this reinforcing feedback is just to let them know that you appreciate what they're doing. This doesn't need to be big things.
Matt Gjertsen [00:09:20]:
This can be, hey, you know, giving them thanks for things they did in the meeting yesterday or how they talked to a client or how they helped each other. It's the small things. Right? But then the way it's done wrong is by just saying, hey, good work. Most people have probably had somebody say, hey, good work, and they had no idea what they were talking about. So if you wanna give reinforcing feedback, this is what do you want people to keep doing, you have to tell them specifically what you want them to keep doing. And this is where I love the SBI model: situation, behavior, impact. Hey, in the meeting yesterday, I really appreciated it when you brought us back to the schedule and reminded us of the things we needed to cover. It made sure that we got through everything And people could do their work as soon as they left because they had the answers they needed.
Matt Gjertsen [00:10:03]:
Right? It was like 2 to 3 sentences, really simple. But now they know, oh, when we get off track, my boss likes it if I bring us back on track. Right? So simple things like that to reinforce, make sure they know, oh, this is the behavior that they were talking about. This is what they want them to keep doing. So you start off asking for feedback. Then you start giving reinforcing feedback. The final step is giving redirecting feedback. What do you want them to change? And this is where people start to get worried, but that's why you— it's so important to keep it simple and every day.
Matt Gjertsen [00:10:40]:
It gets difficult, right? Difficult conversations are difficult because we wait too long. The faster you can give feedback on things you want to change, the lighter of a touch it takes. And this is where SBI is a great model, but there's one thing that's missing. So for redirecting feedback, I like to use the COIN acronym, which stands for context, observation, impact, and then the difference— those 3 steps are very similar. The difference is next steps. So in the meeting yesterday, you interrupted folks a couple times, which made— I felt them less hesitant to share their ideas, and we didn't hear from everyone in the room because people felt uncomfortable. Next time, if you could really make sure to let people finish their thoughts before you give your own, I would really appreciate it. Right now, if you do that the first time you see it, that's— it's just a simple thing.
Matt Gjertsen [00:11:34]:
If it's been happening for 3 weeks and everybody knows about it and everybody's talking behind people's back, that's when it gets difficult. So the way I think this should be implemented is phased out over maybe 3 months. If you are in a— if you yourself are really uncomfortable with feedback, or you're on a team where feedback is not a major thing, then for 1 month, focus exclusively on asking for feedback. Then for 1 month, focus exclusively on giving reinforcing feedback. Because now for 2 months, everybody's seen you're constantly asking them for feedback, you're telling them what they're doing well, and you're really reinforcing that they're doing great work. And so now when you go to give redirecting feedback in the 3rd month, it's gonna feel a lot easier. You're gonna have built up your muscle for giving feedback. They're gonna build up their muscle for hearing feedback, and it's just gonna make the whole thing a whole lot simpler.
Matt Gjertsen [00:12:34]:
And so that's why these things— you can probably tell right now, that's why these things build on one another, right? First, you have to build strong, connected, trusting relationships with your people. So that you can feel free to talk about things. You have to set clear expectations so that people know what they're trying to do, and that's what gives you the benchmark so that you can give feedback on the performance of those expectations. Right? All of these things build on one another, which is why I wrote the book the way that I did because I think they do build on one another, and it builds perfectly to part four, which we're going to get to next time because if you'll notice. The First Principles Leadership Framework only had 3 parts. We've covered all 3. So what's 4? Well, you're gonna have to tune in next time. Come back next week to the closing episode about minimum viable manager so you can find out what it is and then you can do it better yourself.
Matt Gjertsen [00:13:31]:
I'll see you next time.

