78 percent of new managers report feeling unprepared for their new role.
This makes sense because a lot of them will struggle with this new role. I know I did.
After watching hundreds of individuals in organizations like the U.S. Air Force and SpaceX fail when they first get promoted to the position of manager, I can tell you there is a very common reason they don’t make the jump successfully.
It all comes back to their leadership style.
24 years ago, Daniel Goleman of Emotional Intelligence fame, wrote an article for HBR titled Leadership That Gets Results. This article was a summarization of a massive study involving nearly 4,000 corporate leaders with the goal of determining if there were common leadership styles and how those leadership styles affected the business.
They came up with six different styles.
- Coaching leaders focus on improving the performance of individuals on their team.
- Pacesetting leaders want to lead by example and show people the best way to do things.
- Democratic leaders lead by consensus and have everyone agree on the best way forward.
- Affiliative leaders build relationships first and want harmony between members of the team.
- Authoritative leaders create a vision and then rally people behind that vision.
- Coercive leaders demand compliance with a my way or the highway mentality.
In all my years working with technical leaders, the most common style I see from new managers is the Pacesetting style. And it spells disaster.
At first glance, this doesn’t make any sense. Leading by example? Isn’t that what we are supposed to do? Let’s look at this more closely.
Most technical talent get promoted because they are the best in their technical field. They have been outperforming their peers and the result is a promotion. Once they get promoted, they think it is their job to continue to be the best and show others out to be the best at their old role.
This is where things start to break down.
This is where the saying “Great players don’t make great coaches” comes from. Pacesetting leaders may demand a performance level that is beyond the people on the team. They struggle with feedback and coaching because they aren’t sure why people are struggling since they didn’t go through the same struggles. Their frustration leads to micromanagement or just taking over projects for people leading to being overwhelmed.
Fixing this cycle is simple.
Stop trying to do your old job.
When you become a manager, your role fundamentally changes. It isn’t about doing the best work on the team, it is about helping others do the best work on the team. Though getting in the trenches and doing work can be valuable, over the long term, it isn’t a sustainable way to lead a team.
Rather than being at the front of the race setting the pace, leaders should be cheering from the side helping the people on their team have their best race.
That is the true role of a leader.

