It is easy to let being kind go too far.

The first skill that I teach new managers is how to build trust with members of their team. This trust is the foundation of any high performing team. Yet when building a relationship, how do you make sure to also hold people accountable?

Welcome back to the fourth installment of this 5-part series on Google’s Project Oxygen. Each week we are diving into two of the eight behaviors Google identified as necessary for being a great manager. If you are new to the newsletter, check out the rest of the series here.

The book Radical Candor by Kim Scott is an excellent portrayal of the dichotomy in this week’s two behaviors.

  • Express interest in team members’ success and well-being.
  • Be productive and results-oriented.

The way Kim Scott describes the first behavior is by saying that you need to “care personally” about the people on your team and she is totally right. You know who the people on your team are as people, what they enjoy, and whether they are feeling fulfilled.

A great example of this came from a manager training I was at years ago. The facilitator asked how many managers in the room knew the names of the children of the people on their team.

No one did.

That is an example of not caring about your people.

However, caring personally, in Kim Scott’s words, leads to “ruinous empathy” if it is not kept in check by being results oriented.

You have to start by building a strong foundation of trust where you show that you celebrate wins and care about your team members. But you do that so that you can successfully challenge them if they are not meeting expectations.

Gary Vaynerchuk, CEO of VaynerMedia, is a big proponent of leading by empathy. His head of HR is called the Chief Heart Officer. However, he also admits that this leads him to overlook poor results for too long.

The most important thing to remember is that everyone wants to be successful and positive members of the team. It is highly unlikely that someone on your team is actively trying to be a bad employee.

Results always have the last word.

If you let personal connection completely overrule your ability to manage results, everyone’s results will suffer. 

This is the heart of radical candor. If you truly care about the individuals on your team, you will be honest about their performance. That is why this dichotomy isn’t actually a dichotomy. 

The more you care, the more you want to understand your team members as people AND the more you will focus on their results.

Both the good and the bad.

You may be interested in